How to Review an Article
Below are the guidelines for reviewing an article in EKSYDA: Jurnal Studi Ekonomi Syariah after you receive an invitation email from the Editorial Team. If you do not have an account yet, please register via the link: Register and follow the instructions on this page: Author & Reviewer Account Creation Guide.
- Login as a Reviewer;
- Click the Submissions menu, select the My Queue tab, then click the title of the assigned article;
- You will be directed to the review page, which consists of 4 steps. In Step 1 (Request), you will find the article's title and abstract, as well as the manuscript file that can be downloaded for review;
- Still in Step 1, you can also see the review deadline (schedule). You are required to confirm by selecting either to agree (Accept Review, Continue to Step 2) or disagree (Decline Review Request) with the invitation;
- In Step 2 (Guidelines), you will see the Reviewer Guidelines which contain the rules to standardize the assessment of an article;
- Then click Continue to Step 3;
- In Step 3 (Download & Review), you are asked to write your review notes in the provided text boxes. You can provide notes intended for both the Author and Editor, or confidential notes for the Editor only. You can also upload the manuscript file with your annotations or comments using the Upload Reviewer Files menu;
- Still in Step 3, after completing your notes, you are asked to select a decision recommendation (Recommendation) for the article (e.g., Accept Submission, Revisions Required, Resubmit for Review, etc.);
- After selecting your recommendation, please click Submit Review;
- Click OK on the confirmation prompt that appears;
- In Step 4 (Completion), the process is finished. Thank you, you have successfully completed the review.
