How to Review an Article

Here are the steps to conduct a review on an article for As-Salam: Jurnal Studi Hukum Islam & Pendidikan after you receive the Invitation Email from the Editorial Team.

  1. Log in to OJS using your Reviewer account.
  2. Go to the Submissions menu, then select the My Queue tab. Click on the title of the article assigned to you.
  3. You will be directed to the review page which consists of 4 steps. In Step 1 (Request), you can read the Title, Abstract, and download the article manuscript file to be reviewed.
  4. Still in Step 1, note the review due date. Please confirm your availability by clicking the approval button (willing to review) or rejection button (not willing to review).
  5. If you agree, you will proceed to Step 2 (Guidelines). Read the Reviewer Guidelines which contain the standards and ethics of article evaluation for this journal.
  6. Click Continue to Step 3 to proceed to the evaluation stage.
  7. In Step 3 (Download & Review), write down your notes, feedback, and corrections in the provided text boxes. You can separate messages intended specifically for the Editor and messages visible to the Author. You can also upload your annotated manuscript file in the Upload File section.
  8. After completing the evaluation, provide your final decision in the Recommendation dropdown (e.g., Accept Submission, Revisions Required, Resubmit for Review, or Decline Submission).
  9. Once the recommendation is selected, click the Submit Review button.
  10. A confirmation pop-up will appear; please click OK.
  11. In Step 4 (Completion), the process is complete. Thank you, you have successfully completed your article review task!